Sheik vs Dr. Mario: Melee matchup win rate
Sheik wins 58.1% of games against Dr. Mario between equally skilled players, based on 358 tournament games from 2002 to 2026 (90% interval 54.9 to 61.4%). Sheik is favored.
Sheik vs Dr. Mario by year
| Period | Sheik win rate | 90% interval | Games | Raw record | Raw win rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Not ranked: one of the two has too few games | ||||
| 2025 | Not ranked: one of the two has too few games | ||||
| 2024 | Not ranked: one of the two has too few games | ||||
| 2023 | Not ranked: one of the two has too few games | ||||
| 2022 | Not ranked: one of the two has too few games | ||||
| All time | 58.1% | 54.9 to 61.4% | 358 | 225-133 | 62.8% |
The raw record counts every game, so it also reflects who plays each character. The win rate removes that by fitting each player's skill overall, by year and on each character. Single years have fewer games, so their estimates sit closer to 50%.
Sheik vs Dr. Mario stages
Stages change this matchup little. Sheik's win rate ranges from 52.2% on Final Destination to 56.3% on Battlefield, and the intervals overlap.
| Stage | Sheik win rate | 90% interval | Games | Raw record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Battlefield | 56.3% | 54.1 to 58.4% | 45 | 29-16 |
| Yoshi's Story | 56.2% | 54.6 to 58.0% | 14 | 11-3 |
| Dream Land | 55.3% | 53.6 to 57.0% | 12 | 8-4 |
| Pokémon Stadium (counterpick) | 54.3% | 52.4 to 56.1% | 22 | 13-9 |
| Fountain of Dreams | 53.2% | 51.3 to 55.1% | 20 | 10-10 |
| Final Destination | 52.2% | 50.0 to 54.4% | 40 | 30-10 |
Game 1
- Sheik strikes first: Sheik strikes Final Destination, Dr. Mario strikes Battlefield and Yoshi's Story, Sheik strikes Fountain of Dreams, leaving Dream Land (73% of resamples).
- Dr. Mario strikes first: Dr. Mario strikes Battlefield, Sheik strikes Final Destination and Fountain of Dreams, Dr. Mario strikes Yoshi's Story, leaving Dream Land (73% of resamples).
Best of 3
- After Sheik loses a game: Dr. Mario has no clear ban (Battlefield in 50% of resamples), then Sheik has no clear pick (Yoshi's Story in 41% of resamples).
- After Dr. Mario loses a game: Sheik bans Final Destination (85% of resamples), then Dr. Mario picks Fountain of Dreams (73% of resamples).
Best of 5
- After Sheik loses a game: Sheik has no clear pick (Battlefield in 50% of resamples); once Sheik has won there, no clear next pick (Yoshi's Story in 41% of resamples).
- After Dr. Mario loses a game: Dr. Mario picks Final Destination (85% of resamples); once Dr. Mario has won there, then Fountain of Dreams (73% of resamples).
With best play on both sides, Sheik wins 57.4% of best-of-3 sets (90% interval 54.9 to 59.5%) and 58.5% of best-of-5 sets (55.5 to 61.9%).
Ruleset and method
Game 1: the five starters are struck 1-2-2-1 until one is left. The winner of rock-paper-scissors chooses whether to strike first.
Best of 3: before each later game, the winner of the last game bans one of the six stages, then the loser picks from the rest, never a stage they already won on.
Best of 5: no bans. The loser of the last game picks any of the six stages they have not won on.
Stage win rates are fitted on the 83,758 games since 2022 with a recorded legal stage, with player skill removed the same way; Pokémon Stadium includes Frozen Pokémon Stadium. The plan is the best play for both players by backward induction over the whole set, under the Platfight Melee ruleset (July 2026), assuming both players keep these characters. The percentage after a choice is how often the same choice comes out when the fit is redone on 200 resamples of the sets. Method.